Crate brace has shifted against our FR10 connector housing

OwenBrooks0834 · 14 Feb 2025, 20:14 UTC

Closed
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Our FR10 delivery has a split timber brace pressing against the connector housing. The crate corner is crushed and the housing looks marked. Still unpowered. The seller replied 'try it', which does not tell me whether trying it is appropriate. I need an assessment route before this reaches the training bench.

20 replies

WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Leave it off. I'd want someone qualified to inspect that damage before trying power, and I'd tell the seller their 'try it' reply isn't good enough.

17 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to WillAdams0139

That is where I have paused. I have arrival photographs, the carrier receipt and images through the opened lid. I have not moved the brace or connected anything.

19 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

A wider photo would help me follow this. Can you show the brace and arm together without moving the packing? Hard to picture it from a dent alone.

8 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to WillAdams0139

The wide view is already in the receiving photos. I had sent only the cropped damage picture to the seller. I will send the full sequence with captions.

4 points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Ask who will assess it and what they need before transport or unpacking continues. Sometimes the first useful step is an inspection at the receiving site. You don't want three people independently telling you to move it somewhere else.

4 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to LuisBrown0956

I'd ask whether they're sending someone out or just looking at the photos. Get them to spell out what they'll check in the email (before you book anything).

7 points
SA
SamBennett0768
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Label the photos by location and view, with the original files retained; a decent evidence set costs little and helps whoever eventually gets the inspection job.

22 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to SamBennett0768

I'd caption that one 'brace against housing'. We haven't seen inside, so I'd leave any claim about a broken connector for whoever inspects it.

23 points
HA
HarishAbbott0054
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

What did receiving note before the lid came off? The external condition and the internal discovery need a clear sequence, particularly if several people handled the delivery.

18 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to HarishAbbott0054

Owen, is the crushed corner on the driver's sheet? That and your first photos would help here. Anything you add now, mark as a later note.

12 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to HarishAbbott0054

Receiving noted the crushed corner on the delivery sheet. The internal brace was found when the lid was opened after delivery. Two staff were present, and the original photos preserve that order.

13 points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Have you now been given an assessor's name? Your evidence is taking shape, but somebody still needs responsibility for deciding what inspection and handling are appropriate. The delivery account cannot make that technical decision.

14 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to LuisBrown0956

The seller has offered a local service contact. I have asked that contact to review the pictures and propose an inspection scope. No attendance date or handling instructions agreed yet.

17 points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Send them the equipment identification as well. They should confirm they can assess this equipment and this kind of damage before you arrange access or move the crate for their visit.

7 points
SA
SamBennett0768
Replying to LuisBrown0956

And ask what access they need at the visit, because discovering they expected the arm unpacked after you've been told to preserve the packing would be a pain.

13 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to SamBennett0768

They have confirmed the equipment identification and asked that we leave the packing arrangement intact. Their initial visit will assess visible condition and the next inspection steps, not commission the arm.

0 points
HA
HarishAbbott0054
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

That gives planning a defined milestone. I would keep the training date provisional until the assessment establishes what further work is needed.

18 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

Get their findings on paper afterwards, including the bits they couldn't check. I'd hate to pay for that visit and come away with another 'probably fine'.

15 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to WillAdams0139

The visit found external housing damage that needs further examination. We are waiting for the proposed repair and inspection plan. The arm remains unpowered; our training session has been rescheduled.

9 points
WI
WillAdams0139
Replying to OwenBrooks0834

I reckon the next question is what they'll check after the repair. A new housing will look better, but I'd still want to know the arm's been properly checked.

15 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .