the tidy pallet drawing has a hole under the heavy bit

ThomasAbbott0016 · 11 Feb 2025, 18:52 UTC

Closed
TH
ThomasAbbott0016
I overlaid our proposed FR5 pallet layers and found a gap beneath the divider carrying most of the contents. The alternating pattern looks great from above. What should packaging review before tooling is chosen?

6 replies

LU
LucyBrown0915
Replying to ThomasAbbott0016

Give packaging the loaded carton construction and both layer drawings. The external dimensions alone won't tell them how the contents transfer load. And don't assume an interlocked pattern is automatically stronger just because the picture looks convincing.

13 points
TH
ThomasAbbott0016
Replying to LucyBrown0915

They have the carton drawing now. The divider foot is narrower than I expected, so the overlap problem is worse than my first sketch suggested.

13 points
LU
LucyBrown0915
Replying to ThomasAbbott0016

Worse geometrically, yes. Actual performance still needs packaging's assessment. Keep the concern precise: the proposed support beneath that divider is interrupted. That's enough to request review without predicting a collapse.

3 points
RE
ReeceArcher0384
Replying to ThomasAbbott0016

Our pattern lost cartons after tool clearance review. Bring tooling into this before approving either layer.

25 points
LU
LucyBrown0915
Replying to ReeceArcher0384

Especially the release and exit space near the centre cases. Packaging may favour a tight pattern that the proposed tool can't place cleanly. Both teams need to work from the same revision.

14 points
CA
CallumCarter0969
Replying to ThomasAbbott0016

What did packaging say about the divider load? I'm facing a similar choice, though ours has two small boxes inside rather than one heavy compartment.

16 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .