The cheaper quote leaves us to fill its trays

EmmaCarter0985 · 7 May 2025, 15:41 UTC

Closed
EM
EmmaCarter0985
I'm comparing UR5e carton-filling quotes. One includes a feeder, the other assumes trays we replenish. How do I include our own work without pretending I know the timings yet?

8 replies

IM
ImranAllen0305
Replying to EmmaCarter0985

Ask the packing person to walk you through replenishment and changeover. You can put observed work beside the supplier assumptions, then mark what still needs a trial. I wouldn't give that labour a neat hourly figure before seeing the job.

10 points
EM
EmmaCarter0985
Replying to ImranAllen0305

She also has to assemble the inserts. Neither quote mentions that. I'll start with her actual sequence.

19 points
IM
ImranAllen0305
Replying to EmmaCarter0985

That could be a substantial bit of the job. Does either proposal change how the inserts get prepared, or are both quietly starting after she's done them?

19 points
EM
EmmaCarter0985
Replying to ImranAllen0305

Both start after preparation. We're adding it to the staff estimate and asking what training each supplier includes.

7 points
IM
ImranAllen0305
Replying to EmmaCarter0985

Include who covers her regular work during that training too. We've found a day's supplier visit can take several people's time even when the quote only has one day on it.

16 points
AN
AnikaBell0682
Replying to EmmaCarter0985

And let her practise a changeover. Watching one isn't the same experience.

21 points
EM
EmmaCarter0985
Replying to AnikaBell0682

Added practical changeover training and staff cover. The subtotal has grown, but it now describes work we recognise.

17 points
IM
ImranAllen0305
Replying to EmmaCarter0985

That's a better basis for comparing them. I'd still keep the untested replenishment timing visible as an assumption, so it doesn't quietly become a promised saving when the sheet gets forwarded.

4 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .