Our FR5 panel report begins after somebody separates the sheet

EllaAllen0294 · 1 Apr 2026, 15:27 UTC

Closed
EL
EllaAllen0294
The proposed tool seals on a thin aluminium enclosure panel, but the bench report starts with one panel already clear of the stack. Our job starts at the stack and ends in an assembly nest. I need separation, support and release covered before putting a staffing figure beside the FR5 proposal.

16 replies

HA
HazelChan1093
Replying to EllaAllen0294

Ask who separated that sample. Then send a representative stack and the actual receiver details for a full comparison. Include how the system establishes one panel, and how the released panel sits afterwards. The person peeling sheets apart must not disappear just because the camera starts later.

6points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to HazelChan1093

Demonstrator separated it by hand. Supplier acknowledges the report only covers contact on one panel. They are proposing a stack trial with our samples.

8points
JA
JamieBrown0904
Replying to EllaAllen0294

Could manually separated presentation be a useful alternative? I would compare it if your orders are small, but include the person's preparation and replenishment time rather than treating it as free.

20points
MI
MinaArcher0424
Replying to JamieBrown0904

Also check what else that person does while the trial runs. A brief task can still conflict with assembly work at exactly the wrong moment.

5points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to MinaArcher0424

We will compare both. The assembly operator would do manual separation, and already covers inspection, so we are including that overlap in the observation.

20points
FI
FionaAli0238
Replying to EllaAllen0294

What does the proposed extra-panel check show the operator when it cannot decide? I'd want that example in the handover, not only one green single-sheet indication.

-2points
HA
HazelChan1093
Replying to FionaAli0238

Fiona's question belongs in the trial brief. Have the supplier show known single, double and uncertain cases with your panels, and define the response without assuming an uncertain grip can proceed.

11points
JA
JamieBrown0904
Replying to JamieBrown0904

And keep the manual option honest about doubles too. A person presenting sheets doesn't make a second sheet physically impossible.

-1points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to JamieBrown0904

Both briefs include that. Supplier has our panels and nest details. We have not accepted either feed arrangement yet.

9points
MI
MinaArcher0424
Replying to EllaAllen0294

Does the panel-support comparison use the same nest in both options? Otherwise you may be comparing a prepared single panel with an easier destination as well.

14points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to MinaArcher0424

Same nest. First stack trial found a double pickup, which its proposed check detected. The single panel reached the nest with a raised corner, so support through release needs attention.

8points
HA
HazelChan1093
Replying to EllaAllen0294

Have them compare the released panel condition before changing the nest to pull it flat. It matters whether the handling changed the panel or the current supports simply fail to let it settle.

10points
FI
FionaAli0238
Replying to EllaAllen0294

Did they show the uncertain indication as well, Ella?

19points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to FionaAli0238

Yes, using a deliberately ambiguous test sample; it held for review. On the corner issue, the accepted single panel was flat before handling and after removal, but did not settle on the proposed receiving supports.

4points
JA
JamieBrown0904
Replying to EllaAllen0294

That sounds worth taking to the support designer with the actual panel. Don't let a successful double check close a separate landing problem.

5points
EL
EllaAllen0294
Replying to JamieBrown0904

Designer is reviewing the contact arrangement. Both feed options remain open, with their labour observations retained; no change to the panel specification or acceptance of the FR5 tool yet.

8points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .