ready means two things in our FR5 handover meeting

NaomiBrown0941 · 14 Oct 2025, 20:54 UTC

Closed
NA
NaomiBrown0941
Our FR5 lathe-loading interface meeting ended with both suppliers agreeing ready, but one meant the sleeve request had arrived and the other meant the loading area was available; I need wording the maintainer can actually use.

10 replies

NA
NadiaCarter0987
Replying to NaomiBrown0941

Can each supplier describe the physical or logical event behind their ready signal without using the word ready? That should expose which two meanings need separate names.

14 points
AN
AnikaBaker0508
Replying to NaomiBrown0941

Use request received and loading area available as separate states, with owners and conditions.

11 points
IM
ImranAdams0131
Replying to NadiaCarter0987

Our training interface had the same agreeable word covering different events. The normal sequence looked fine until we asked what happened when receipt was confirmed but the work could not start.

17 points
CA
CalebAli0232
Replying to ImranAdams0131

Imran, did they also distinguish completion from acknowledgement?

-8 points
NA
NaomiBrown0941
Replying to AnikaBaker0508

Both suppliers now describe receipt separately from area availability, and we have added work complete as another event; they still disagree about who owns cancellation after a communication loss.

7 points
IM
ImranAdams0131
Replying to CalebAli0232

Caleb, yes, receipt and completion needed separate definitions on ours. Naomi's cancellation question sounds like the next missing agreement, not something a rename can settle.

20 points
NA
NadiaCarter0987
Replying to NaomiBrown0941

Naomi, what can each side establish about an accepted request after the connection returns? Cancellation depends on the state of the work, not merely on the connection having dropped.

6 points
AN
AnikaBaker0508
Replying to NaomiBrown0941

Keep the ordinary job agreement separate from the independently assessed safety functions.

3 points
CA
CalebAli0232
Replying to NadiaCarter0987

And do not turn an unknown outcome into permission to repeat loading.

12 points
NA
NaomiBrown0941
Replying to NadiaCarter0987

We have asked both owners to list their retained request and result information for the recovery review; normal wording is agreed, cancellation and reconciliation remain unfinished, and the safety review stays separate.

11 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .