The old bracket check says fine, then says bend it

RebeccaAllen0343 · 19 Apr 2025, 12:05 UTC

Closed
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
I'm sorting our bracket paperwork before the FR10 project review. First sheet says aligned in fixture. Next says outside tolerance after release, then correct. Who should explain what correct actually meant?

18 replies

HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Start with the welding lead and whoever signed the final inspection. The word alone doesn't tell you what was done or how they judged it finished.

8 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to HenryAdams0090

Final inspector is still here. The setter who did the correction has retired. Typical timing.

11 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Does the inspector have the actual readings?

9 points
WI
WillBarnes0574
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Also ask whether correction was routine or limited to particular batches; that changes how much hidden work your new production plan may be inheriting.

10 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to WillBarnes0574

Useful distinction. A single rework case isn't the normal cycle.

13 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to WillBarnes0574

Found it on several batches. Still can't tell whether every bracket needed it or somebody copied the note across the traveller.

4 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Then leave that frequency unknown for now.

6 points
EL
EllaArcher0381
Replying to HenryAdams0090

Do the sheets identify the bracket before and after correction? We had batch totals that couldn't tell us whether a recheck was the same piece.

15 points
GR
GraceBennett0755
Replying to EllaArcher0381

Keep the pre-correction and final readings separate when transcribing them. The final accepted value is useful, but replacing the earlier value would erase the problem you are trying to understand.

20 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to GraceBennett0755

Yes, don't tidy the awkward bit out of the data.

9 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to EllaArcher0381

Inspector has a notebook with individual IDs and final readings. No matching measurements before correction. I've asked him about the gap, not filled it in from the batch sheet.

5 points
WI
WillBarnes0574
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

That's useful final evidence, although it won't tell you how much correction each bracket needed. Has the welding lead found a written method?

8 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to WillBarnes0574

Not yet. He remembers the setter using a separate bench fixture, which isn't on our equipment list.

6 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Find that fixture before budgeting away the setter's job.

14 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to HenryAdams0090

Stores thinks it may be in the old tooling rack. I've asked them to identify it properly; not dragging out the first vaguely bracket-shaped thing.

13 points
EL
EllaArcher0381
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Could the inspector recognise it from a photo? That might narrow the search before someone moves heavy tooling around.

3 points
RE
RebeccaAllen0343
Replying to EllaArcher0381

Good idea, he's looking at the rack photos with stores. The review now lists an unexplained correction and possibly missing tooling. Less tidy than our original plan, more honest.

20 points
HE
HenryAdams0090
Replying to RebeccaAllen0343

Worth finding now. Post back if they locate it; curious what that little word was hiding.

5 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .