Can our FR5 keep every filled carton facing the same way?

CarlaChen1184 · 7 Apr 2026, 07:42 UTC

Reply to discussion
CA
CarlaChen1184
I want to drop the rotated layer from our FR5 proposal. Our filled cartons have two support strips underneath, and the rotated drawing puts one strip partly above a finger channel. Packaging has shown me the problem on a section, so this isn't another argument about how pretty the pattern looks. The straight arrangement carries fewer cartons per layer. I can live with that if the full stack and tool withdrawal work, but dispatch is treating the original carton count as something sacred. What else should we compare before I push the lower-count option?

7 replies

AN
AnikaAbbott0073
Replying to CarlaChen1184

Compare the whole stack, not just a better first layer.

18 points
CA
CarlaChen1184
Replying to AnikaAbbott0073

That's the missing drawing. We have a straight first layer and then the old rotated layers pasted above it. I hadn't noticed until I tried to count them.

2 points
AN
AnikaAbbott0073
Replying to CarlaChen1184

Send it back. Nobody can assess the stack you actually want from that.

8 points
RO
RobinChan1121
Replying to CarlaChen1184

Would the lower count mean another pallet for your usual dispatch quantity? Could still be worthwhile, but give dispatch the real difference rather than just telling them to like fewer cartons.

0 points
AN
AnikaAbbott0073
Replying to RobinChan1121

Fair question. Add finished pallet height and the actual removal arrangement to that comparison.

17 points
CA
CarlaChen1184
Replying to RobinChan1121

Robin, one common order needs an extra pallet with the straight layout. Dispatch wasn't just being awkward. Packaging is willing to review that complete stack, and tooling has the filled-carton sections. I've asked costing to include the extra pallet handling instead of burying it.

21 points
RO
RobinChan1121
Replying to CarlaChen1184

That's a useful disagreement now. I wouldn't buy back the carton count by adding a support sheet unless someone also owns getting that sheet in and out.

14 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.