ready went high before the lathe finished preparing

RebeccaBell0691 · 4 Sept 2026, 09:39 UTC

Reply to discussion
RE
RebeccaBell0691
I'm comparing the proposed UR5e handshake charts and the machine simulator raises ready as soon as it receives our request, while the robot chart advances into loading on that same signal; I need wording that stops both suppliers defending different meanings of one word

10 replies

SA
SarahBrooks0850
Replying to RebeccaBell0691

We had an equivalent disagreement with a docking interface; could both suppliers annotate one request trace with what physical or logical condition each transition actually represents?

20 points
RE
RebeccaBell0691
Replying to SarahBrooks0850

The machine team annotated its trace and confirms ready means request queued, not preparation complete; I've put that beside the robot transition which currently assumes access is available

17 points
SA
SarahBrooks0850
Replying to RebeccaBell0691

That trace makes the mismatch visible, thank you; ask them to name receipt and preparation completion separately, with the ordinary sequence interface kept distinct from the safety-related permission requirements.

18 points
RE
ReeceAli0210
Replying to RebeccaBell0691

Who owns a request that is accepted but never finishes preparing? That isn't a rare philosophical edge case. Somebody will have to explain the timeout to the operator and decide what recovery is permitted.

7 points
SA
SarahBrooks0850
Replying to ReeceAli0210

Include that stalled-preparation example in the same review, since a normal successful trace won't settle who detects the wait or who clears the outstanding request.

20 points
RE
RebeccaBell0691
Replying to SarahBrooks0850

Both teams are reviewing the normal trace and a preparation timeout now; the machine team says it can expose a separate completion condition, but the reset and interruption behaviour is still being agreed

10 points
SA
SaraBarnes0548
Replying to RebeccaBell0691

Who removes the completion condition after a transfer, and before the next request?

19 points
NA
NathanBrown0895
Replying to RebeccaBell0691

Have they actually agreed a new interface, or only agreed that another signal is possible? Those are different milestones. The operator recovery instructions depend on the finished transition definitions.

17 points
SA
SarahBrooks0850
Replying to NathanBrown0895

I read the update as an available option, not a completed agreement; the clearing question above needs an answer before the normal trace itself is fully defined.

10 points
RE
RebeccaBell0691
Replying to NathanBrown0895

Option only, yes; I've marked the interface draft unresolved and removed the robot transition based on request queued from the approved proposal, pending the joint definition and review

1 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.