damaged fr5 enclosure, seller's answer is switch it on

AnikaBennett0769 · 24 Jun 2026, 08:39 UTC

Reply to discussion
AN
AnikaBennett0769
Crate corner crushed, supports shifted and visible damage near the controller enclosure; I kept the packaging and photos, and the FR5 remains unpowered despite the seller's suggestion to try it

11 replies

SA
SamArcher0420
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

Who can authorise a qualified assessment of the damaged unit before energisation? A seller's switch-on suggestion does not establish its condition.

7 points
AN
AnikaBennett0769
Replying to SamArcher0420

Our equipment lead has kept it isolated in receiving; seller has not named an assessor or offered anything beyond the power-on message

6 points
FE
FelixArcher0371
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

Send the serial and damage-location photos with the receiving record and ask for a written assessment or return proposal. Keep the crate and shifted supports as found where practical. Don't open or straighten the enclosure to make the photographs clearer; qualified inspection should decide what happens next.

1 points
AN
AnikaBennett0769
Replying to FelixArcher0371

That request is sent through purchasing, with the unopened enclosure and retained packaging identified; equipment lead will not accept a remote guess about internal condition

19 points
TO
TobyBaker0492
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

Have they acknowledged the enclosure damage specifically? It would help distinguish an actual response to your concern from a standard commissioning reply.

10 points
OM
OmarChan1100
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

And keep the power-on instruction in the correspondence. It explains why you asked for a different route.

18 points
AN
AnikaBennett0769
Replying to TobyBaker0492

They acknowledge the visible damage now and have referred it to their service coordinator; no qualified inspection findings, so the isolation stays

2 points
SA
SamArcher0420
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

Has the coordinator proposed inspection at your site or a documented return, including who arranges handling of the damaged consignment?

5 points
FE
FelixArcher0371
Replying to SamArcher0420

If they choose return, get the packing and collection arrangements assessed too. The original supports shifted, so put it back how it came is not a useful transport plan for this unit.

19 points
TO
TobyBaker0492
Replying to AnikaBennett0769

Anika, does your equipment lead have a named service contact now? That would make the next action something receiving can follow instead of another open-ended instruction from sales.

16 points
AN
AnikaBennett0769
Replying to TobyBaker0492

Yes, Toby; coordinator has offered a return for assessment, subject to agreed protective packing and collection details. Purchasing and our equipment lead are checking those terms. Nothing repacked, powered or collected yet

5 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.