Why rank the FR10 when the demos unload into different trays?

YasminChan1050 · 21 Feb 2026, 21:26 UTC

Closed
YA
YasminChan1050
Both sleeve demos moved parts. Only one used our receiving tray. What comparison would settle the extra handling?

17 replies

OS
OscarBennett0706
Replying to YasminChan1050

What happens to the sleeves after the demonstration tray is full? Ask for that before comparing the robot cycle times.

6 points
YA
YasminChan1050
Replying to OscarBennett0706

Our tray goes to assembly. Their demonstration tray would need unloading into ours first.

13 points
CA
CallumAllen0273
Replying to YasminChan1050

Did either demonstration show release into the awkward pockets, or did the video stop while the sleeve was still held?

13 points
AI
AishaBarnes0605
Replying to YasminChan1050

Price the transfer between trays as a distinct option. It may still be workable, but the person doing it and the space for both trays belong in that price.

8 points
YA
YasminChan1050
Replying to CallumAllen0273

Callum, our-tray demo showed release. Two sleeves needed the demonstrator to straighten them afterwards.

25 points
LE
LeahAdams0147
Replying to YasminChan1050

Then ask what the ordinary loader would do with those two. I'd want the supplier to explain the placement problem before a tutor quietly inherits a manual finishing step.

19 points
AN
AnilAbbott0027
Replying to LeahAdams0147

Leah, manual finishing might be an honest option if it is acceptable and costed. The trouble is presenting it as an autonomous transfer and then telling the loader it is only an occasional touch.

11 points
CH
ChenChan1051
Replying to AnilAbbott0027

Two out of how many? Occasional needs a denominator.

5 points
OW
OwenAli0225
Replying to YasminChan1050

Were those two pockets damaged, or were they ordinary examples of the tray you intend to use? I would not ask a new tool to accommodate scrap without first knowing the distinction.

14 points
YA
YasminChan1050
Replying to ChenChan1051

Two out of twelve sleeves. Tray inspected and acceptable for assembly use; those pockets are not damaged.

2 points
LU
LucyChan1089
Replying to AnilAbbott0027

Anil's option deserves a price, not a euphemism. Include the loader examining the tray, identifying a poor placement, and putting it right through an agreed method. Counting only the seconds spent straightening two sleeves will flatter it.

9 points
LE
LeonBriggs
Replying to LucyChan1089

And show how the loader knows a sleeve is properly seated afterwards

22 points
VA
Val_Bailey
Replying to YasminChan1050

Does assembly accept a different tray at all? Could remove the second transfer, if they do.

16 points
CA
CarlaArcher0401
Replying to Val_Bailey

Worth asking, Val, but also who returns the empty trays. We once priced new trays and forgot the collection job entirely.

9 points
YA
YasminChan1050
Replying to Val_Bailey

Assembly will consider another tray, provided its fixture interface stays unchanged. Supplier is pricing a compatible receiving tray.

4 points
LE
LeahAdams0147
Replying to AnilAbbott0027

That changes the choice usefully. Anil, I accept your point about a costed manual option; I'd keep it beside this new tray proposal until the actual placement and handover are demonstrated.

25 points
OS
OscarBennett0706
Replying to YasminChan1050

Has the proposed receiving tray been assessed at assembly yet, including the fixture interface and empty return? I would hold the shortlist until that answer joins the handling cost.

8 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .