Our FR5 controller-area arrival damage needs an assessment plan

AnnaBaker0503 · 22 Aug 2026, 17:41 UTC

Reply to discussion
AN
AnnaBaker0503
My FR5 sample-placement delivery has a crushed crate corner, displaced supports and visible damage near the controller enclosure. I have retained the packing and arrival photos and left it unpowered. Seller says switch it on, with no assessment procedure. I need a qualified review of the condition.

18 replies

CA
CarlaBaker0488
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Ask the seller to name a qualified assessor and a damage-specific procedure. Your photographs and retained packing are useful; a general power-on suggestion does not establish the condition of the damaged equipment.

8 points
JA
JamieChan1078
Replying to CarlaBaker0488

Include the displaced supports in that referral, not only the close-up of the enclosure damage.

18 points
TH
ThomasAli0190
Replying to JamieChan1078

Who is keeping the delivered equipment and packaging identified together while the enquiry runs, so the later reviewer can connect the close-up to the actual arrival?

10 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to ThomasAli0190

Stores has both under the delivery reference. The photo set includes the crate, support positions and exterior damage. We have not opened the enclosure or attempted repair.

14 points
TO
TobyAllen0318
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Has a technical person actually received that set, or is sales still the only contact?

10 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to TobyAllen0318

Sales forwarded it and copied a service coordinator. The coordinator has acknowledged receipt but not nominated an assessor. I asked them to identify who will decide the inspection scope.

18 points
CA
CarlaBaker0488
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Ask when they will answer that nomination question. Forwarding is a correspondence step, not an inspection booking, and your installation planner should still see the equipment as awaiting assessment.

-6 points
JA
JamieChan1078
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Have them say what further exterior information is missing instead of asking you to open things for a better picture.

23 points
TH
ThomasAli0190
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

And keep any account of movement since arrival with the record; it helps the assessor distinguish the documented delivered condition from later handling.

21 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to CarlaBaker0488

Assessor nominated. They reviewed the exterior set and asked to attend before proposing inspection work beyond it. The appointment is being arranged; nobody has authorised power or repair.

17 points
TO
TobyAllen0318
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Is the visit for assessment only, or have they sent a repair proposal as well?

9 points
CA
CarlaBaker0488
Replying to TobyAllen0318

Keep those decisions separate. A service visit can establish a repair scope without authorising the proposed repair or releasing the setup for use.

16 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to TobyAllen0318

Assessment only, confirmed. Purchasing will receive the findings with me. The visit is booked, and the installation team has the hold noted against our sample-placement plan.

14 points
JA
JamieChan1078
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Ask for findings and limitations, not merely a replacement-part quotation after the visit.

13 points
TH
ThomasAli0190
Replying to JamieChan1078

That will also tell maintenance what remains unexamined, rather than leave them to infer an inspection scope from whichever part appears on the quote.

6 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to JamieChan1078

Visit completed. The assessor documented the damaged enclosure area and identified further inspection needed under their procedure before defining the repair. We received the written findings; the setup remains unpowered.

18 points
AN
AnnaBaker0503
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Seller has now offered to arrange that further assessment. Purchasing is clarifying its scope and cost before agreeing. The initial suggestion to switch on is no longer their proposed next step.

23 points
CA
CarlaBaker0488
Replying to AnnaBaker0503

Keep the assessment offer with the findings it is meant to address. That gives you a concrete next decision without treating the offer itself as evidence the damage has been resolved.

23 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.